Why a profitable project can go bankrupt: operating profit versus cash shortfalls

Financial model · Cash flows · Capital V2
A financial model can show a positive result for the year, yet by week eight the project may have no money to pay prizes, salaries or a contractor’s invoice. Future revenue does not pay today’s obligations. When checking a game economy, I therefore examine the operating result, cash movements and the minimum funding needed to meet obligations at every point in time separately.
Source material: the FIGHTEX economic simulator case study.
Three questions that one number cannot answer
Operating result
shows whether recognised income covers expenses over the chosen period. A positive result describes the economics of that period, but not the sequence of receipts and payments within it.
Cash flow
shows actual receipts and payments. Accrued revenue may still be held by a payment intermediary, while an awarded prize may remain in a player’s internal balance. Recognition and the transfer of money happen at different times.
Capital requirement
answers a different question: how much available funding is needed to keep the cash balance above the agreed reserve. This checks the entire path over time, rather than its final point alone.
The distinction between profit and cash flows is also reflected in the IFRS Foundation’s description of IAS 7: under the indirect method, profit is adjusted for items including non-cash transactions and timing differences. For an engineering model, it is useful to maintain two linked ledgers from the outset: accruals and actual payments.
Illustrative example: a profit, but too little cash at the start
Consider four consecutive launch phases. All amounts below are hypothetical and in dollars; this is an illustrative model, not FIGHTEX results. For simplicity, receipts and payments correspond to income and expenses within each phase. Development costs, taxes and interest are not modelled here: a complete budget needs separate lines for them.
| Phase | Receipts | Payments | Cumulative cash flow F | Reserve R | R − F |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 6 000 | 10 000 | −4 000 | 8 000 | 12 000 |
| 2 | 6 000 | 10 000 | −8 000 | 8 000 | 16 000 |
| 3 | 8 000 | 9 000 | −9 000 | 5 000 | 14 000 |
| 4 | 14 000 | 3 000 | 2 000 | 4 000 | 2 000 |
Over the four phases, receipts total 34 000 and payments total 32 000: the result is positive, at +2 000. However, the minimum initial operating capital required is 16 000. With that funding, 8 000 remains in cash after phase two, exactly matching the required reserve. Starting with 12 000 still leaves a positive cash balance, but after phase two it is only 4 000 against a requirement to hold 8 000.
The launch date must also be checked separately. If a reserve of 8 000 is needed before any receipts arrive, include it as phase 0 with zero cumulative cash flow. A monthly table can also hide a shortfall within the month: large payments require a daily timeline or a sequence of cash events.
How to calculate the capital requirement
Let Ft be cumulative cash flow excluding investor contributions and borrowing, and Rt the required cash reserve on the same date. If capital K is fully available before launch, the condition is K + F_t ≥ R_t. Therefore:
K_min = max(0, max_t(R_t − F_t)).
Without a reserve, the cash shortfall in our example is 9 000. The peak reserve is 8 000. Adding their separate maxima to obtain 17 000 is not the exact calculation: those peaks occur in different phases. Calculating the difference on each date gives 16 000. If the project already has 10 000 of unrestricted cash, the additional funding required under these conditions is 6 000.
This formula assumes that capital is available immediately and is not withdrawn. Funding in tranches, a credit facility and restricted funds require a separate funding schedule. A promised tranche arriving after the point of deficit does not close an earlier shortfall.
What Capital V2 means
The name Capital V2 does not define a metric on its own: it identifies a version of a particular model’s methodology, rather than a generally accepted financial standard. Verification requires the reserve components, the period they cover and the cash flow calculation rules.
For example, a project may agree a reserve covering several weeks of operating expenses and prizes, plus a separate marketing allowance. If the allowance M0 is constant, it can be included in the requirement: K_min = max(0, max_t(R_t + M_0 − F_t)). Variable marketing expenditure requires a timeline, rather than an automatically selected average.
A marketing campaign that has already been paid for appears in cash flow. A reserve for future marketing is a cash balance requirement. These are different events; each needs a defined date and purpose so that the same future payment does not enter the reserve twice.
Unwithdrawn prizes remain liabilities
If a player has been awarded a prize but has not requested a withdrawal, the money physically remains with the project. It cannot automatically be treated as unrestricted cash. The accrual ledger records an expense and a liability; the cash ledger records a payment when the player withdraws. The reserve must cover the outstanding liability according to the agreed rules.
It is easy to overstate capital here: first deduct an awarded prize from cash, then reserve the same amount again. The opposite error is to remove a player’s balance from liabilities when the player stops being active. A change in user status does not, by itself, discharge the amount owed to that user.
What to check before deciding to launch
I start with the payment schedule and reserve rules, then test delayed receipts, faster prize withdrawals, weak conversion and additional expenses. Each scenario needs the minimum balance, the date of maximum deficit, the capital requirement and the headroom below the investor’s limit. An average across random runs does not replace checking each run: the average may fit the budget while some paths exceed it.
A positive profit does not guarantee the ability to pay on every date. Equally, breaching an internal reserve policy does not in itself establish legal bankruptcy. The model identifies a specific financial constraint that must be addressed through funding, changes in timing or an agreed revision of obligations.
Frequently asked questions
Why might a profitable project run out of cash?
Profit describes the result for a period, while payments occur on specific dates. Expenses and obligations may fall due before receipts arrive; even a positive result for the year does not cover that earlier shortfall.
Can the maximum cash shortfall and peak reserve simply be added together?
An exact calculation compares the reserve and cumulative cash flow on each date. Their separate maxima may occur at different times. In the illustrative example, adding the peaks gives 17 000 dollars, while the calculation by date gives 16 000 dollars.
What does Capital V2 mean?
It identifies a version of a particular model’s methodology, rather than a universal financial standard. Checking the metric requires the reserve components, the period covered, cash flow rules and the treatment of marketing.
