Why reducing game asset issuance can increase financial losses

FIGHTEX — stage A6.2 / A6.3-R
FIGHTEX · A6.2; verification: A6.3-R

GameFi · Asset issuance · Repeat payments

Limiting game asset issuance is often proposed as a way to reduce excess supply: fewer free cards mean less pressure on the market. However, the financial result also depends on how cards are linked to game access, expiry and repeat payments. A mechanism that reduces issuance can sometimes remove part of the revenue at the same time.

Source material: the FIGHTEX economic simulator case study.

The example below is hypothetical. All rules and amounts are chosen to explain the relationship; they are neither FIGHTEX financial results nor a description of an approved change to that project.

Issuance is a flow; the number of cards is a stock

Issuance measures how many new assets appear during a period. Stock measures how many exist or are available for a particular action. For a class of cards, the relationship can be written as: closing stock = opening stock + issuance − destruction − expiry, if expired cards leave the stock being measured.

Issuance can be reduced in different ways: limit free pack distribution, increase the cost of obtaining a card in internal points, change pack contents or extend the life of existing cards. These decisions affect different parts of the economy. A change in the number of Common cards does not, on its own, explain a change in cash receipts.

For example, extending a card’s life reduces the need to replace it. Limiting free packs while keeping the same lifetime may instead make it harder to return to the game. The same reduction in issuance can therefore have different effects on payments and activity.

Where the link to a paid slot arises

Suppose a card occupies a game slot. The slot’s paid mode remains active until the card expires; a new card requires a separate activation. In this design, revenue depends on the number of repeat activations, which in turn depends on how often cards are replaced and whether the user decides to pay again.

The chain is: method of limiting issuance → card replacement frequency → number of repeat activations offered → share of activations paid for → net receipts. Each link needs support from rules or data. If payment remains valid after the card is replaced, a key link in this chain is absent.

Voluntary removal, sale, crafting and expiry may have different conditions. Not every event that frees a slot can automatically be counted as a new payment. It is also necessary to check whether an unused paid period is retained and whether refunds are possible.

The calculation: issuance halved, losses increased

Suppose a hypothetical steady-state model has 1 000 occupied game positions at all times, with one card per position. Card ages are uniformly distributed. An expired card is immediately replaced with a free card, and 20% of replacements involve a paid activation. Before the change, a card lasts 30 days; afterwards, 60 days. Months are treated as exactly 30 days, with no transition period.

The activation price is 4 dollars, and variable processing and servicing costs are 1 dollar. Each payment therefore contributes 3 dollars towards other expenses. The assumed cost of issuing and processing each new card is 0.05 dollars; this is an example parameter, not a fee charged by a particular network.

Monthly result with unchanged audience and payment share
Metric30-day lifetime60-day lifetime
Replacements and new cards1 000500
Paid activations: replacements × 20%200100
Activation receipts$800$400
Contribution after variable costs$600$300
Card issuance costs$50$25

Suppose other receipts, net of their associated variable costs, are 200 dollars and total fixed expenses are 900 dollars. Before the change, the monthly result is 600 + 200 − 900 − 50 = −150 dollars. Afterwards, it is 300 + 200 − 900 − 25 = −425 dollars. A saving of 25 dollars comes with a loss of 300 dollars in payment contribution; the loss increases by 275 dollars.

In this example, payments and revenue recognition coincide over the fixed horizon, so the operating result equals the cash result for the flows listed. In a real product, payout delays, refunds and prepayments require a separate cash schedule. The difference between monthly results cannot simply be called an increase in the capital requirement: that must be determined together with cumulative cash flow and reserves.

Counterexample: monetisation may be unaffected

Change just one rule: the user buys access for a calendar month, and replacing a card does not cancel that payment. Extending card life then does not automatically reduce the number of payments. With purchases and activity unchanged, the saving on card processing improves the result.

Another case is a cap that affects only excess distribution. If players still receive enough cards to behave as before, while card lifetime and payment rules remain unchanged, the revenue-loss mechanism described above may never be triggered. A cap could improve the market; confirming its effect requires demand and executed trades to be considered.

How to test the mechanism in a simulator

  1. First record exactly what changes: the number of cards distributed, their lifetime or paid-slot conditions. Test each mechanism separately and in combination. If distribution, price and conversion all change within one configuration, it becomes harder to explain the result.

  2. Keep the initial cohorts and external conditions the same. For a stochastic model, compare sets of runs and record the seeds. Using the same seed is useful, but does not guarantee the same path if the order of random events changes: a strict paired comparison needs coordinated random-number streams or saved external events.

  3. The event log should record why a card leaves use, when a slot is freed, the renewal offer, payment, refund and actual cash receipt. Reconcile not just total revenue, but also the number of replacements, repeat payment share, active positions, churn, fees, operating result and maximum cash deficit. This detail helps identify the cause of a difference.

What to agree before changing the rules

First define the problem being targeted: excess assets, weak demand, servicing costs or a funding deficit. Then set limits for each related metric. Better issuance figures do not mean the financial criteria have been met, and higher revenue does not establish that the new rules benefit players.

Frequently asked questions

Does reducing issuance always reduce revenue?

No. The effect depends on how issuance is limited and how payment works. In the example, extending card life reduces replacements and repeat activations. With a calendar subscription that remains valid after replacement, this revenue-loss mechanism does not arise automatically.

Why did the loss increase despite the saving on issuance?

Paid activations fell from 200 to 100 per month. Their contribution decreased by 300 dollars, while the saving on processing new cards was 25 dollars. All else being equal, the monthly loss increased by 275 dollars.

Which metrics should be compared after changing issuance?

Besides issuance, track card replacements, repeat payment share, active positions, churn, fees, operating result and maximum cash deficit. Compare scenarios under comparable external conditions with the calculation rules recorded.

Related materials

Continue the analysis: how card supply relates to market liquidity, reserves and changes in financial requirements.

The connection between card lifetime and other mechanics is described in the public FIGHTEX economic simulator case study. The process for agreeing new rules is covered in the article on re-auditing a financial model. For your own product, a tokenomics and economic model audit helps connect asset supply, user behaviour and cash obligations in a single calculation.


Let’s discuss your project

Tell me what you would like to build. I will reply by email.

Or message me on Telegram @ifwcom